An examination of killers and kidnappers who manage to commit terrible crimes while leading seemingly ordinary lives. Their double lives are reconstructed with the help of personal images and interviews of those involved.
In rural Ohio, an intruder guns down Jack and Linda Myers in their sleep. Footage unearthed from their home movies captures a monster lurking in their midst.(S02,E01)
The Yates family moves to Spokane to find it hit by a serial killer targeting young women. The family's home videos expose one of America's most infamous killers.(S02,E02)
When Frank Hilley is struck down by a mysterious sickness, the town of Anniston grieves. But suspicions arise after his daughter also falls seriously ill. (S02,E03)
In Albuquerque, Mike Snyder starts a family with his partner, capturing it on home video. But after being diagnosed with a serious illness, he vanishes.(S02,E04)
After taping their TV show in rural Vermont, Chrissy and Charlie Billis have a terrible car accident. Only one survives. Do tapes offer a clue to what happened?(S02,E05)
In Colorado, the idyllic life of spouses Harold and Toni Henthorn is shattered by a deadly hiking accident. But their happy home videos conceal a deadly predator.(S02,E06)
After moving to a remote Colorado town, Ron and Cynthia Phillips and their kids struggle to adjust. But their home videos mask darker impulses that lead to murder.(S02,E07)
Outside LA, sword collector Neal Williams is the house-husband and wife Manling supports the family – until Manling finds her family slaughtered at sword point.(S02,E08)
Ohio biker Richard Beasley values family, faith and helping others. When he vanishes, police find an online monster has been luring local men to their deaths.(S02,E09)
In Pennsylvania, Kevin and Joanne Dowling like to capture their kids' milestones on video. But when a woman in a nearby town is shot dead, Kevin is accused of murder.(S02,E10)